I haven’t blogged for a while. There’s been a few things going on. You know minor, insignificant things like being on a clinical trial for my secondary breast cancer. Waiting to watch the new James Bond. Visiting animal sanctuaries. Not to mention the whole global pandemic thing. It’s been an exciting time!
So shocker I’m still alive and kicking 4 years and 2 months post my diagnosis with stage 4 breast cancer. I’m still dying in my 30s though so don’t party too hard. Unless you don’t like me. In which case party away people!
I’m working extremely hard to live and live well for as long as possible. I love the rollercoaster that is my life. I really don’t want it to end. So you might ask why I’m so supportive of assisted dying and the UK group Dignity in Dying. After all they want to bring in assisted dying for the terminally ill. How could someone desperate to live support that. In my case easily. In fact my question would be why anyone wouldn’t support that. This blog aims to respond to some objections people have raised to me either directly or via social media.
Wouldn’t assisted dying lead to the mass slaughter of the disabled?
No it wouldn’t. The change supported by Dignity in Dying just deals with terminally ill people with a few months to live. If you aren’t dying, then you wouldn’t be able to use the initiative. End of. People of sound mind would have to choose to die in advance, in some cases a few days before they would naturally. There are built in safeguards. Those safeguards have worked in multiple countries. Why not here in the UK? Countries that have legalised assisted dying haven’t seen abuse of the process. I have multiple disabilities not even counting my cancer. Protecting disabled rights is something I care about. If this measure threatened disabled people I’d oppose it.
Suicide is a sin. God disapproves.
Firstly assisted dying isn’t suicide. When I run out of cancer treatment options I will die. I could die slowly and “naturally”. Or I could die the way I’ve lived – on my own terms.
Secondly I don’t believe in any God so why should other people’s beliefs condemn me to a slow and painful death? If you believe in God I’m happy for you. Just don’t get assisted dying if you feel that way.
Thirdly has anyone asked God for an opinion on assisted dying lately? How do you know God disapproves? Maybe just maybe God inspired the creation of the assisted dying drugs to save people from suffering. Maybe God believes in free will and compassion. After all assisted dying for the terminally ill that want it is a blessing and a kindness. I was raised in the Christian faith. I remember how much kindness was part of the faith. So be kind.
You’re being melodramatic and a coward. Dying isn’t that horrible. You’re just suicidal
This was the perspective of someone on social media. My response was to ask them how they knew that. Had they died of cancer recently? They blocked me!
Palliative care is awesome. But it isn’t perfect. Same for hospice care. Have you ever been in a hospital bed screaming silently in agony because your voice gave out hours before from screaming? Only to be told they can’t give you more pain meds yet? I have. I have a disability in my foot. It causes me constant pain. I haven’t had a pain free day in over 10 years. But I still get out of bed every morning, have multiple hobbies and work full time as well as dealing with cancer. I’m no coward. But I also can’t believe my pain will be controlled when I die. After all it never has in normal life, despite many Dr’s best efforts. I’ve felt the pain of cancer eating my ribs. Knowing I’ll feel that again in my dying days gives me regular nightmares.
As part of my cancer treatment I’ve had radiation pumped into my body, voluntarily taken chemo pills which had big red biohazard warnings on the label. I’ve gone through the menopause. I’ve gone through morphine withdrawal by myself. I am no coward. I do all of that to live and live well for as long as possible. Don’t you dare call people like me suicidal. We are literally the complete opposite.
Plus it’s always worth noting that countries who pass assisted dying laws often simultaneously boost funding for palliative and hospice care. So win win that benefits everyone.
But assisted dying shortens lives and deprives families of time with the dying person
Assisted dying shortens death. I have incurable secondary breast cancer. I’m 37. I’m going to die of cancer unless covid etc catches me first. But my death in my 30s is a certainty.
Plus I really object to the whole “what about the family” argument.
Firstly when I die my death will and should be all about me. If you can’t be the primary person of importance at your own death, when can you? I really don’t care about what my family thinks. I’m dying in my 30s so my chorus and verse is “me, me, me”.
Secondly have you ever been around a dying relative? I have. My mother and 3 grandparents. It sucked big time. My mother died in 2000. I’m still traumatised by how she died and that my last memory of her is mum lying on a hospital bed with tubes everywhere and unable to talk. I struggle to remember my grandparents as healthy and active. When I picture them, I picture them dying.
My husband will hopefully live 60 years after I die. Why should his last memory be of me lying on a bed dying? Why should he have to remember me in pain or with bed sores and bowel issues? Why should he have to dread missing my last breath if he dozes off? He shouldn’t have to go through that. Anyone who supports that system is incomprehensible to me. I want him to remember me smiling, not dying.
It’s just wrong. Life is precious
Life is precious I agree. But I believe in quality of life. Everything that makes me most happy involves me being up and out of bed. It involves me having energy and strength. When I lose my strength and mobility I will lose nearly everything that makes me who I am today. I won’t get years to adapt and find new interests. Once I run out of treatments I’m on a one way journey to death. But I want a smooth and peaceful journey. I want to live, but I want more than existing. It’s hard enough dying at my age without the thought of dying as a shadow of myself.
But it will be cruel to the medical professionals treating you if they have to prescribe lethal meds
Under our current laws I can write an advanced care plan for when I’m unable to advocate for myself. As part of that I can proactively refuse treatment that would keep me breathing for longer. I can order the removal of nutrition to hasten my death. I can pick a whole range of ways medical professionals can kill me faster by not treating me. Many British people choose these heartbreaking and undignified deaths to end their suffering. What I can’t do though is ask them to prescribe a drug to stop the suffering. I can’t ask them to end the pain. Doctors are first meant to do no harm. What’s more harmful to me? Declining the thyroid meds I need to live and dying in a particularly nasty way or taking a dose of meds at a time of my choosing and falling asleep forever in the arms of my husband?
What I don’t understand is that for pets there literally is no choice in the matter. If you leave a dog to die “naturally” of cancer you’d probably be prosecuted. If you put the dog down and let it die being cuddled by it’s beloved human you’re a compassionate hero. Why is it the opposite for humans? Am I really worth less care and consideration than a dog?
If I’ve persuaded you about why I support Dignity in Dying, please sign their vital petition and say yes to dignity and compassion – https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/604383
